I agree that HasphatsAnts' list is the most accurate.
The only thing about it that I think is truly debatable is whether I or II is worse. It varies for me, but ultimately, I think the Anakin/Padme "romance" is so unbearable that I'd rather watch Jar Jar than that garbage.
And I guess one could disagree with the placement of IV over VI, but personally, I think the ewok crap in VI puts it clearly below IV, even with IV being very rough around the edges.
The only thing about it that I think is truly debatable is whether I or II is worse. It varies for me, but ultimately, I think the Anakin/Padme "romance" is so unbearable that I'd rather watch Jar Jar than that garbage.
And I guess one could disagree with the placement of IV over VI, but personally, I think the ewok crap in VI puts it clearly below IV, even with IV being very rough around the edges.
IV has real charm and earnestness that VI is lacking. Plus Ford and Fisher clearly give no fucks in VI. Everything good in that comes in the throne room.
VI hits a higher high than any of the Star Wars movies with the Emperor/Luke/Vader Mexican standoff, but everything on the Endor Moon is basura.
Revenge of the Sith was an absolutely deplorable film. Even the "best" scenes contained something contemptible in them.
And Attack of the Clones was, somehow, even worse in every way.
And Attack of the Clones was, somehow, even worse in every way.
By Elchele Go To PostI love you HasphatsAnts, but 3 is clearly better than 6. Please understandNo way. It's watchable for a prequel movie, but Jedi is still far superior to Sith. I hate the logic behind Anakin turning to the dark side. Rather than being a Shakespearean fall like it's intimated to be in the original films, a bratty kid gets tricked into murdering a bunch of kids. This is to say nothing of the rest of the nonsense plot, the standard prequel god awful dialog ("From my point of view, the Jedi are evil."), the mind numbing, soulless action set pieces.
Sith still sucks.
It may be the superior film, I can't deny it. But I prefer to watch ep 3 than ep 6 any day, it's more enjoyable.
By Elchele Go To PostIt may be the superior film, I can't deny it. But I prefer to watch ep 3 than ep 6 any day, it's more enjoyable.
Why must you hurt me like this.