Gamespot (Kevin VanOrd)
9/10

THE GOOD
  • Agile, precise combat makes even the most difficult encounters fun
  • Fantastic artistry with a clear and inviting visual arc
  • Surreal religion-themed story goes big--very big
  • Lithe, energetic boss battles featuring phenomenal creatures
  • Interconnected world makes every discovery a wonder

  • THE BAD
  • Long load times
  • Disappointing chalice dungeons

  • Gameinformer (Daniel Tack)
    9.75/10

    Concept: Hunt through the night in the cursed city of Yharnam in search of a cure
    Graphics: Beautiful backdrops and environments bring the horror to life
    Sound: Groans, shrieks, and the sound of bells punctuate the journey. The amazing soundtrack highlights everything from the serene and peaceful to adrenaline-fueled boss battles
    Playability: You get some instruction at the beginning, but players learn new things the whole way through. A difficult and demanding single-player experience with multiplayer components that can provide solace for those who seek it
    Entertainment: An unsettling, Lovecraftian adventure through nightmares that constantly tests and enthralls the player. Just when you think you have things figured out, new elements come into play
    Replay: High

    Destructoid (Chris Carter)
    9/10

    Bloodborne is an interesting mix of everything From Software has learned throughout its storied developmental career. Not everything will gel with fans old and new, but for the most part, the shift towards a combat-oriented game is a net positive. From Software is still one of the only developers left that makes you work for your satisfaction, and Bloodborne is damn satisfying.

    Superb: A hallmark of excellence. There may be flaws, but they are negligible and won't cause massive damage to what is a supreme title.

    Jimquisition (Jim Sterling)
    10/10

    Bloodborne is something truly special – a barbaric horror RPG that will giveth and taketh away in perfect measure, wrapped up in a perverse world that will refuse to let you go.

    EGM (Josh Harmon)
    9.5/10

    The Good: A new take on From Software’s Souls formula that’s quicker and less obtuse without sacrificing the punishing difficulty.
    The Bad: Chalice Dungeons, while mildly entertaining, are a shadow of what they might have been.
    The Ugly: The Blood-Starved Beast, who reminds me of a girl I once dated. You’ll understand.

    The Escapist(Mitchell Saltzman)
    4.5/5

    Bottom Line: While the load times are a pretty big bummer, it doesn't change the fact that Bloodborne's combat is sublime, its challenge is second to none, and its world is unforgettable.

    Recommendation: Bloodborne, like the rest of the Souls games, isn't going to be for everyone. But, if you're the patient sort and are willing to put in the time and effort to get good at Bloodborne's complex and punishing combat, you'll find Bloodborne nearly impossible to put down.
    Top